Skip to main content

(MX03US02) - Photo Read Validation

Photo Read Validation (MX03US02) - Comprehensive Test Cases

Test Scenario Analysis

A. Functional Test Scenarios

  1. Core Reading Validation Workflow - Validator can process readings through Pass/Exempt/Revisit/Adjust actions
  2. Cycle Management - Display and navigate through reading cycles with accurate counts
  3. Estimation Engine - Apply three estimation methods with business rule compliance
  4. New Meter Processing - Add new meters to system with proper validation
  5. Route Transfer Operations - Transfer meters between routes with audit trail
  6. Batch Operations - Process multiple readings simultaneously (Supervisor only)
  7. Service Order Creation - Generate service requests from meter validation
  8. GPS and Location Validation - Validate meter location accuracy within 100m tolerance
  9. Consumption Analytics - Display historical consumption with anomaly detection
  10. Data Export and Integration - Export validated readings for billing system

B. Non-Functional Test Scenarios

  1. Performance - Page load <3s, API response <500ms, concurrent user handling
  2. Security - Role-based access, data protection, audit trails
  3. Compatibility - Cross-browser, responsive design, device compatibility
  4. Usability - Navigation flow, error handling, user experience
  5. Reliability - Data integrity, error recovery, system stability

C. Edge Case & Error Scenarios

  1. Boundary Conditions - Min/max consumption values, GPS tolerance limits
  2. Invalid Inputs - Malformed readings, unauthorized access attempts
  3. System Failures - Network timeouts, service unavailability
  4. Data Inconsistencies - Duplicate meters, missing estimation data

Test Cases

TC_001: Core Reading Validation - Pass Reading

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_001
Title: Validator can successfully pass a valid meter reading
Created By: Test Automation
Created Date: 2025-06-03
Version: 1.0

Classification:

  • Module/Feature: Reading Validation
  • Test Type: Functional
  • Test Level: System
  • Priority: P1-Critical
  • Execution Phase: Smoke
  • Automation Status: Planned-for-Automation

Enhanced Tags: MOD-ReadingValidation, P1-Critical, Phase-Smoke, Type-Functional, Platform-Web, Report-QA, Customer-Enterprise, Risk-Low, Business-Critical, Revenue-Impact-High, Integration-End-to-End

Business Context:

  • Customer_Segment: Enterprise/SMB/All
  • Revenue_Impact: High
  • Business_Priority: Must-Have
  • Customer_Journey: Daily-Usage
  • Compliance_Required: Yes
  • SLA_Related: Yes

Quality Metrics:

  • Risk_Level: Low
  • Complexity_Level: Medium
  • Expected_Execution_Time: 2 minutes
  • Reproducibility_Score: High
  • Data_Sensitivity: High
  • Failure_Impact: Critical

Test Environment:

  • Environment: Staging
  • Browser/Version: Chrome 115+, Firefox 110+, Safari 16+
  • Device/OS: Windows 10/11, macOS 12+
  • Screen_Resolution: Desktop-1920x1080
  • Performance_Baseline: <1 second response

Prerequisites:

  • User logged in with Validator role
  • Active reading cycle available (May 2025 Cycle)
  • Meter M100001 in Pending status
  • Valid meter reading data present

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Navigate to Meter Read Guardian dashboard

Dashboard displays with cycle information "May 2025 Cycle: 01/05/2025 to 31/05/2025"

-

Verify cycle dates

2

Click on "View Readings" tab

List view shows all readings with status counts

-

Check count accuracy

3

Select meter M100001 from list

Detailed view opens showing meter information

Meter: M100001, Status: Pending

Verify all sections load

4

Review meter reading details

Previous: 3602, Current: 3900, Consumption: 298

Consumer 1, ACC-200001

Check calculation accuracy

5

Verify meter image and GPS status

Image displays, GPS status shows "GPS Mismatch" flag

Distance: 62.0 meters

GPS within tolerance

6

Click "Pass" button

Reading status changes to "Passed", moves to Pass tab

-

Verify status update

7

Navigate to Pass tab

Meter M100001 appears in Pass list with count increment

Pass count: 342

Verify count update

Verification Points:

  • Primary_Verification: Reading successfully moved to Pass status
  • Secondary_Verifications: Tab counts updated, audit trail created
  • Negative_Verification: Reading should not appear in other status tabs

TC_002: Reading Exemption with Reason Code

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_002
Title: Validator can exempt reading with mandatory reason code selection
Priority: P1-Critical

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter M100001 in detailed view

Meter details displayed

Meter: M100001

-

2

Click "Exempt" button

Exempt Reading modal opens

-

Modal validation

3

Verify reason code dropdown is empty

"Select a reason code" placeholder shown

-

Required field check

4

Click "Exempt" without selecting reason

Error message or button disabled

-

Validation check

5

Select reason code "EX-01: Meter Inaccessible"

Reason code selected and highlighted

EX-01: Meter Inaccessible

Valid selection

6

Click "Exempt" button

Modal closes, reading exempted

-

Action completion

7

Verify reading moved to Exemptions tab

Count increases, meter appears in list

Exemptions: 125

Status verification


TC_003: Manual Reading Adjustment

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_003
Title: Validator can manually adjust reading value with consumption calculation
Priority: P1-Critical

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter M100001 in detailed view

Meter details displayed

Current: 3900, Previous: 3602

-

2

Click "Adjust" button

Adjust Reading modal opens with tabs

-

Modal validation

3

Verify "Manual Adjustment" tab is active

Tab highlighted, form fields visible

-

Default tab check

4

Enter adjusted reading value

Consumption automatically calculated

New reading: 4444

Real-time calculation

5

Verify consumption calculation

"Consumption will be: 842" displayed

4444 - 3602 = 842

Math verification

6

Click "Adjust" button

Modal closes, reading adjusted

-

Action completion

7

Verify reading status updated

Status shows "Adjusted" in Pass tab

Status: Adjusted

Status verification


TC_004: Estimation Rule Application

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_004
Title: Validator can apply estimation rules for missing readings
Priority: P1-Critical

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Navigate to Missing Readings tab

List of 130 missing readings displayed

-

Tab navigation

2

Select meter M100002 with missing reading

Meter details show previous reading only

Previous: 2850 (01/04/2025)

Missing current

3

Click "Adjust" button

Adjust Reading modal opens

-

-

4

Click "Apply Estimation" tab

Estimation options displayed

-

Tab switch

5

Select "Average Consumption" radio button

Option selected with description

3-month average

Method selection

6

Click "Apply Estimation"

Estimation calculated and applied

Estimated: 3148 (298 avg)

Calculation check

7

Verify reading moved to Pass tab

Status shows "Estimated"

Status: Estimated

Status update


TC_005: Batch Estimation for Missing Readings (Supervisor)

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_005
Title: Supervisor can apply batch estimation to all missing readings
Priority: P2-High

Prerequisites:

  • User logged in with Supervisor role
  • Multiple meters with missing readings available

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Navigate to Missing Readings tab

130 missing readings displayed

-

Initial count

2

Click "Estimate All" button

Estimate All Missing Readings modal opens

-

Batch modal

3

Verify count display

"114 missing readings" shown in modal

114 readings

Count accuracy

4

Select "Same Month Last Year" option

Radio button selected

May 2024 data

Method selection

5

Click "Estimate All" button

Processing indicator shown

-

Batch processing

6

Wait for completion

Modal closes, success message displayed

-

Process completion

7

Verify Missing Readings count reduced

Count decreases significantly

New count: 16

Batch result

8

Check Pass tab for estimated readings

Multiple readings with "Estimated" status

Status: Estimated

Status verification


TC_006: New Meter Registration

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_006
Title: Supervisor can add new meter to system with proper validation
Priority: P2-High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Navigate to New Readings tab

Shows 3 new readings

-

Tab access

2

Select meter NEW-86754

New meter details displayed

Reading: 100, Status: new

New meter

3

Click "Add Meter to System" button

Add Meter modal opens

-

Modal validation

4

Verify auto-populated serial number

Serial number field shows NEW-86754

Serial: NEW-86754

Auto-population

5

Check device number field

Shows "NM202505001"

Device: NM202505001

Device validation

6

Select route from dropdown

Current route selected

Route: Current Route

Route assignment

7

Select premise from dropdown

Premise options available

Premise 1

Premise selection

8

Click "Confirm" button

Modal closes, meter added

-

Addition complete

9

Verify meter appears in system

Meter with "unassigned" status created

Status: unassigned

System update


TC_007: Route Transfer Operation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_007
Title: Supervisor can transfer meter between routes with audit tracking
Priority: P2-High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter DEV-78901 with different route status

Meter shows "registered_different_route"

From Route B

Wrong route

2

Click "Transfer to Route" button

Transfer modal opens

-

Transfer option

3

Verify source route information

Shows "Route B to your current route"

From: Route B

Source identification

4

Select destination route

Dropdown shows available routes

To: Route A

Destination selection

5

Select destination premise

Premise options for selected route

Premise 2

Premise assignment

6

Review transfer implications

Bulleted impact list displayed

Update assignments

Impact awareness

7

Click "Transfer Meter" button

Transfer completed, modal closes

-

Transfer action

8

Verify meter route updated

Status changed to normal route assignment

Status: normal

Route verification

9

Check activity log for transfer record

Transfer logged with timestamp and user

Log entry created

Audit trail


TC_008: Service Order Creation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_008
Title: User can create service order for meter requiring field service
Priority: P3-Medium

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter NEW-86754 requiring service

New meter displayed

Status: new

Service needed

2

Click "Create Service Order" button

Create Service Order modal opens

-

Service modal

3

Verify meter identification

Shows target meter "NM202505001"

Target: NM202505001

Meter reference

4

Select priority from dropdown

Priority options available

Priority: Medium

Priority setting

5

Enter service description

Text area accepts input

"Uninstall ghosted meter"

Description entry

6

Click "Create Service Order" button

Service order submitted

-

Order creation

7

Verify confirmation message

Success notification displayed

"Service order created"

Confirmation

8

Check service order tracking

Order appears in service management

Order ID generated

Tracking setup


TC_009: GPS Mismatch Detection and Handling

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_009
Title: System detects and flags GPS location mismatches beyond tolerance
Priority: P1-Critical

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter M100001 with GPS data

Location information displayed

Lat: 37.766992, Long: -122.399930

GPS coordinates

2

Check distance difference

"62.0 meters" shown in red

Distance: 62.0m

Within tolerance

3

Verify GPS mismatch flag

"GPS Mismatch" warning displayed

Flag: GPS Mismatch

Automatic detection

4

Review location vs registered address

Address matches: "123 Main Street, Cityville"

Address verification

Location validation

5

Check route assignment

Shows "Route D"

Route: Route D

Route accuracy

6

Verify reading can still be processed

Pass/Exempt/Adjust buttons available

-

Processing allowed

7

Pass reading with GPS mismatch

Reading processes with GPS flag retained

Flag preserved

Flag retention


TC_010: Consumption History Analysis

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_010
Title: System displays consumption history with anomaly detection
Priority: P2-High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter M100001 detailed view

Consumption History section visible

-

History access

2

Review monthly consumption chart

Bar chart shows 5 months of data

Dec-Apr data

Visual display

3

Identify normal consumption months

Blue bars for typical usage

Dec: 299, Jan: 340, Feb: 282, Mar: 271

Normal pattern

4

Identify anomaly month

Red bar for unusual usage

Apr: 702 (>50% average)

Anomaly detection

5

Verify current reading context

May consumption: 298 (normal pattern)

May: 298

Current validation

6

Check daily average calculation

Shows "Avg: 9.93 per day"

298รท30 = 9.93

Math accuracy

7

Use history for validation decision

Historical pattern supports current reading

Decision: Pass

Context usage


TC_011: Mark Reading for Revisit

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_011
Title: Validator can mark reading for revisit with reason tracking
Priority: P2-High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open meter M100001 requiring review

Meter details displayed

-

Initial state

2

Click "Revisit" button

Mark for Revisit modal opens

-

Revisit option

3

Verify reason code requirement

Dropdown shows "RV-01: Suspicious Reading"

Selected: RV-01

Reason required

4

Review reason code description

Full description of suspicious reading

Description visible

Reason clarity

5

Click "Mark for Revisit" button

Modal closes, reading marked

-

Action completion

6

Verify reading moved to Revisit tab

Count increases, meter in Revisit list

Revisit: 134

Status update

7

Check reason code in list view

Reason code displayed in list

Code: RV-01

Reason tracking


TC_012: Cross-Browser Compatibility Validation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_012
Title: Meter validation interface functions across supported browsers
Priority: P2-High

Enhanced Tags: MOD-Compatibility, P2-High, Phase-Regression, Type-Compatibility, Platform-Web, Report-Engineering, Customer-All, Risk-Medium, Business-High, Cross-Platform-Support-Web

Test Environment:

  • Browsers: Chrome 115+, Firefox 110+, Safari 16+, Edge Latest
  • Screen_Resolution: 1920x1080

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Open application in Chrome

Dashboard loads correctly

-

Chrome test

2

Navigate through all tabs

All navigation functions work

All tabs accessible

Chrome navigation

3

Process a reading validation

Pass/Exempt/Adjust/Revisit all function

Meter M100001

Chrome functionality

4

Repeat steps 1-3 in Firefox

Identical functionality and appearance

-

Firefox test

5

Repeat steps 1-3 in Safari

Identical functionality and appearance

-

Safari test

6

Repeat steps 1-3 in Edge

Identical functionality and appearance

-

Edge test

7

Compare visual consistency

UI elements aligned and styled consistently

-

Cross-browser UI

8

Test modal dialogs in all browsers

All modals open, close, and function properly

-

Modal compatibility


TC_013: Mobile Responsive Design Validation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_013
Title: Interface adapts properly to mobile and tablet screen sizes
Priority: P3-Medium

Test Environment:

  • Screen_Resolution: Mobile-375x667, Tablet-1024x768
  • Device/OS: iOS 16+, Android 13+

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Access dashboard on mobile device

Navigation tabs stack or scroll horizontally

-

Mobile layout

2

View meter details on mobile

Information sections stack vertically

Meter M100001

Mobile detail view

3

Test action buttons on mobile

Buttons remain accessible and properly sized

Touch-friendly size

Mobile interaction

4

Open modals on mobile screen

Modals scale to fit screen without overflow

-

Mobile modal

5

Test on tablet resolution

Layout adapts to tablet dimensions

-

Tablet layout

6

Verify touch interactions

All touch gestures work properly

-

Touch functionality

7

Test horizontal/vertical orientation

Layout adapts to orientation changes

-

Orientation handling


TC_014: Performance Benchmark Validation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_014
Title: System meets performance requirements under normal load
Priority: P2-High

Enhanced Tags: MOD-Performance, P2-High, Phase-Performance, Type-Performance, Platform-Web, Report-Engineering, Customer-Enterprise, Risk-Medium, Business-High, SLA-Related-Yes

Quality Metrics:

  • Expected_Execution_Time: <1 second per operation
  • Performance_Baseline: Page load <3s, API response <500ms

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Load dashboard with 500+ readings

Page loads within 3 seconds

500 meter records

Initial load time

2

Switch between tabs

Tab content loads within 1 second

All tabs

Tab switching

3

Open meter detail view

Detail view loads within 1 second

Meter M100001

Detail load time

4

Process reading validation

Action completes within 1 second

Pass action

Validation speed

5

Apply batch estimation

100 readings processed within 10 seconds

100 missing readings

Batch processing

6

Export readings data

Export completes within 5 seconds

500 records

Export performance

7

Monitor API response times

All API calls respond within 500ms

Various endpoints

API performance


TC_015: Data Validation and Business Rules

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_015
Title: System enforces all business rules and data validation constraints
Priority: P1-Critical

Enhanced Tags: MOD-DataValidation, P1-Critical, Phase-Smoke, Type-Functional, Platform-Web, Report-QA, Customer-All, Risk-High, Business-Critical, Compliance-Required-Yes

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Attempt to enter negative consumption

System prevents or flags invalid data

Reading: 3000 (previous: 3500)

Negative consumption rule

2

Try to process reading outside cycle dates

System validates cycle date constraints

Date: 15/06/2025

Cycle validation

3

Test GPS tolerance enforcement

Reading flagged when >100m from registered location

Distance: 150m

GPS tolerance

4

Verify estimation rule priority

System applies highest priority available rule

Missing estimation data

Rule priority

5

Test duplicate meter prevention

System prevents duplicate device numbers

Device: M100001

Duplicate prevention

6

Validate mandatory reason codes

System requires reason for exempt/revisit

Empty reason field

Mandatory fields

7

Check role-based restrictions

Validator cannot access supervisor functions

Batch operations

Role enforcement


TC_016: Security and Access Control Validation

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_016
Title: System enforces proper security controls and access restrictions
Priority: P1-Critical

Enhanced Tags: MOD-Security, P1-Critical, Phase-Security, Type-Security, Platform-Web, Report-Engineering, Customer-Enterprise, Risk-High, Business-Critical, Data-Sensitivity-High, Compliance-Required-Yes

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Login with Validator role

Access granted to validation functions only

User: validator@utility.com

Validator access

2

Attempt to access batch operations

Button/function not visible or disabled

Estimate All button

Role restriction

3

Try to add new meters

Add Meter function not accessible

New meter functions

Supervisor only

4

Login with Supervisor role

Access granted to all functions

User: supervisor@utility.com

Supervisor access

5

Verify audit trail creation

All actions logged with user and timestamp

Various actions

Audit logging

6

Test session timeout

Session expires after inactivity period

30 min inactivity

Session management

7

Verify data encryption

Sensitive data transmitted securely

Network inspection

Data protection


TC_017: API Integration Testing

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_017
Title: API endpoints function correctly for reading validation operations
Priority: P1-Critical

Enhanced Tags: MOD-Integration, P1-Critical, Phase-Integration, Type-API, Platform-Web, Report-Engineering, Customer-Enterprise, Risk-High, Business-Critical, Integration-External-Dependency

Quality Metrics:

  • Expected_Execution_Time: <500ms per API call
  • Data_Sensitivity: High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Call GET /api/readings/cycle/{cycleId}

Returns reading list with 200 status

Cycle: May2025

Reading retrieval

2

Call POST /api/readings/{id}/validate

Updates reading status successfully

Reading: M100001, Action: pass

Validation API

3

Call POST /api/readings/{id}/exempt

Exempts reading with reason code

Reason: EX-01

Exemption API

4

Call PUT /api/readings/{id}/adjust

Updates reading value and consumption

New value: 4444

Adjustment API

5

Call POST /api/estimations/batch

Processes multiple estimations

100 readings

Batch estimation

6

Call POST /api/meters/add

Adds new meter to system

New meter data

Meter addition

7

Call PUT /api/meters/{id}/transfer

Transfers meter between routes

Route transfer data

Route transfer

8

Verify error handling

API returns proper error codes for invalid requests

Invalid data

Error responses


TC_018: End-to-End Billing Integration

Test Case ID: MX03US02_TC_018
Title: Validated readings export correctly for billing system integration
Priority: P1-Critical

Enhanced Tags: MOD-Integration, P1-Critical, Phase-Integration, Type-Integration, Platform-Web, Report-Product, Customer-Enterprise, Risk-High, Business-Critical, Revenue-Impact-High

Test Procedure:

Step

Action

Expected Result

Test Data

Comments

1

Complete validation for full cycle

All readings have final status

May 2025 cycle

Cycle completion

2

Navigate to Pass tab

All validated readings visible

341+ readings

Export preparation

3

Click Export button

Export dialog opens

-

Export initiation

4

Select billing system format

CSV format selected for billing

Format: CSV

Format selection

5

Generate export file

File downloads with validated data

Readings data

File generation

6

Verify export data format

CSV contains all required billing fields

Standard billing format

Format verification

7

Test billing system import

Billing system accepts exported data

Billing system test

Integration test

8

Verify billing cycle completion

Readings appear in billing with correct values

Bill generation

End-to-end verification


Test Suite Organization

Smoke Test Suite (Critical Path)

  • TC_001: Pass Reading Validation
  • TC_002: Reading Exemption
  • TC_015: Data Validation Rules
  • TC_016: Security Access Control
  • TC_017: Core API Functions

Execution: Every build deployment
Duration: 15 minutes
Automation: 100%

Regression Test Suite (Full Functional)

  • TC_001 through TC_011: All core functionality
  • TC_014: Performance benchmarks
  • TC_015: Business rules validation
  • TC_017: API integration
  • TC_018: Billing integration

Execution: Before each release
Duration: 4 hours
Automation: 80%

Full Test Suite (Complete Coverage)

  • All test cases TC_001 through TC_018
  • Cross-browser compatibility testing
  • Mobile responsive validation
  • Performance under load testing
  • Security penetration testing

Execution: Weekly or major release
Duration: 8 hours
Automation: 60%

Integration & Dependency Map

External Dependencies

  1. GPS Services - Location validation (TC_009)
  2. Billing System API - Export integration (TC_018)
  3. Authentication Service - User access control (TC_016)
  4. File Storage - Meter images and exports (TC_001, TC_018)

Test Execution Dependencies

  1. Prerequisites: User accounts, test data, active cycle
  2. Sequential: New meter tests must run before route transfer
  3. Parallel: Reading validation tests can run simultaneously
  4. Failure Impact: Security test failures block all other tests

Performance Benchmarks

Critical Performance Criteria

  • Page Load Time: <3 seconds for dashboard with 500+ readings
  • API Response Time: <500ms for all validation operations
  • Batch Processing: 100 readings estimated in <10 seconds
  • Export Generation: 1000 readings exported in <5 seconds
  • Concurrent Users: Support 50 simultaneous validators

Load Testing Scenarios

  • Normal Load: 25 concurrent users processing readings
  • Peak Load: 50 concurrent users during cycle end
  • Stress Test: 100+ concurrent users with degraded performance monitoring